UnMasking The Cabal

[Goldude]

By assaulting Joe, by mail and by internet violence, they have attempted to bully the entirety of us. Perhaps a demonstration of our abilities is needed now. Besides, should not we ascertain who we are dealing with in the Cabal. We as well have a Gurt Lime Man (I am not aware of who he is) upon our side.

Hey, don't lump me into a side I don't take. I'm Chaotic Neutral, not anything go- wait, what? HOW CAN YOU NOT KNOW WHO GURT IS?!?

[AceOfSpades]

Not only that but its pretty much making any innocent fictionals like Sherlock look bad.

[WackyMeetsPractical]

By assaulting Joe, by mail and by internet violence, they have attempted to bully the entirety of us. Perhaps a demonstration of our abilities is needed now. Besides, should not we ascertain who we are dealing with in the Cabal. We as well have a Gurt Lime Man (I am not aware of who he is) upon our side.

Hey, don't lump me into a side I don't take. I'm Chaotic Neutral, not anything go- wait, what? HOW CAN YOU NOT KNOW WHO GURT IS?!?

She's new.

[Guyshane]

By assaulting Joe, by mail and by internet violence, they have attempted to bully the entirety of us. Perhaps a demonstration of our abilities is needed now. Besides, should not we ascertain who we are dealing with in the Cabal. We as well have a Gurt Lime Man (I am not aware of who he is) upon our side.

Hey, don't lump me into a side I don't take. I'm Chaotic Neutral, not anything go- wait, what? HOW CAN YOU NOT KNOW WHO GURT IS?!?

She's new.

I hope so. because everyone knows Lime man will save us all

[AceOfSpades]

Not jumping to any conclusions, but what if MR. A is Angelus. I am just saying, beacause well in an analogy sense, Moriarty posed as a founder of the League of Extraordinary gentlemen once.

[Dryunya]

That would be highly unlikely. Just because, well, if he found them all by those means, he wouldn't have to respond in such dramatic manner like he did when they were found.

[AceOfSpades]

Maybe that's how he wants us to think, anyone can act dramatic with practice.

[Inukai44]

This is just speculation but what if The Cabal got Joan's notebook?

[Adell]

This is just speculation but what if The Cabal got Joan's notebook?

They did. The voicemail messages were from them, and they mention the book in it.

[NeverSlender]

This is just speculation but what if The Cabal got Joan's notebook?

One of the voice messages said they did.

[Inukai44]

Oh didn't see that

[IslaKariese]

Oh didn't see that

S'okay. There's a lot of stuff to follow.

[NeverSlender]

Oh didn't see that

No problem, there's loads of stuff to keep track of now, it's getting difficult.

EDIT: Ninja'd.

[Dame763]

My thoughts on the identities of the Cabal, for what it's worth. (Being until this very moment, a lurker.)

Angelus: The Phantom of the Opera aka The Angel of Music

Pyramus: Peter Pan- This was based more on the posts than anything. The fact that P asked if the notes had to be handwritten just seemed like a child trying to get out of work to me.

Steinitz: Probably Moriarty as Lisovek said.

Oberon: Again, I agree that Oberon is Morgana.

[Zup]

My thoughts on the identities of the Cabal, for what it's worth. (Being until this very moment, a lurker.)

Angelus: The Phantom of the Opera aka The Angel of Music

Pyramus: Peter Pan- This was based more on the posts than anything. The fact that P asked if the notes had to be handwritten just seemed like a child trying to get out of work to me.

Steinitz: Probably Moriarty as Lisovek said.

Oberon: Again, I agree that Oberon is Morgana.

I don't think Peter Pan corresponds to the cover image from the comic all that well. The other three certainly are plausible.

[Dryunya]

Peter Pan was seen by the Tinfoil Hat guy. It's not exactly clear whether or not he was among those who came to threaten him, and that's all the evidence we have about him. And, to be honest, Peter Pan in Cabal... That just doesn't make sense.

[AceOfSpades]

Peter Pan was seen by the Tinfoil Hat guy. It's not exactly clear whether or not he was among those who came to threaten him, and that's all the evidence we have about him. And, to be honest, Peter Pan in Cabal... That just doesn't make sense.

Exactly, why would a boy, whose dedication of staying youthful to prevent his demise want to associate himself with adults that stand to harm others?

Also about my earlier accusation of Mr. A I had to do a lot of looking over but there are a few things that strengthen it:

1. The obvious, Angelus with the same first letter as Administrator.
2. Both Angelus and A are leaders of their respective organizations.
3. Both use "We" alot albeit on different meanings.
4. Both are the first aware of Joe's findings in his investigation before he started the forum. A acknowledging him while Angelus threaten's him.

[Scarab]

Peter Pan was seen by the Tinfoil Hat guy. It's not exactly clear whether or not he was among those who came to threaten him, and that's all the evidence we have about him. And, to be honest, Peter Pan in Cabal... That just doesn't make sense.

Exactly, why would a boy, whose dedication of staying youthful to prevent his demise want to associate himself with adults that stand to harm others?
Also about my earlier accusation of Mr. A I had to do a lot of looking over but there are a few things that strengthen it:
1. The obvious, Angelus with the same first letter as Administrator.
2. Both Angelus and A are leaders of their respective organizations.
3. Both use "We" alot albeit on different meanings.
4. Both are the first aware of Joe's findings in his investigation before he started the forum. A acknowledging him while Angelus threaten's him.

This is a very good point, and my main reason for NOT believing it's Peter Pan. This just doesn't fit with his character. Authur's sister, however... I am fully ready to believe Morgan le Fey is part of the Cabal, and we know there's one female, British sounding member. I considered the possibility of Mordred too due to the fact that there's a connection between Morgana le Fey and Oberon in some old medieval text (she's his mother in that... with Julius Ceasar, no less, don't ask me how that works ), although I doubt it would be both of them, unless they just haven't realised their connection to each other yet.

[Tohrinha]

I also think that the Phantom is part of the Cabal. There's not only what seems to be him on the cover, but one of the callers seems to have a French accent.

[Dryunya]

I have finally got to search the Phantom of the Opera... Yep, that's him on the cover. That half-mask says it all.

I also think that the Phantom is part of the Cabal. There's not only what seems to be him on the cover, but one of the callers seems to have a French accent.

You probably mean message 6 / threat 2: "killed many people for stumbling in the wrong place at the wrong time". Is that applicable to Phantom?

I also think the Tinfoil Hat's site was a last-resort hint in case we couldn't discover their identities by ourselves, which we have found prematurely.

[AceOfSpades]

I have finally got to search the Phantom of the Opera... Yep, that's him on the cover. That half-mask says it all.

I also think that the Phantom is part of the Cabal. There's not only what seems to be him on the cover, but one of the callers seems to have a French accent.

You probably mean message 6 / threat 2: "killed many people for stumbling in the wrong place at the wrong time". Is that applicable to Phantom?

I also think the Tinfoil Hat's site was a last-resort hint in case we couldn't discover their identities by ourselves, which we have found prematurely.

It could be, the Phantom himself almost killed the love of his life when she unmasked him for the first time.

[The Wild West Pyro]

Nope.

The Phantom just got very angry, and frightened Christine badly.

[AceOfSpades]

And now he along with the rest of the group react to Joe's investigation in anger.

[Pixelmage]

You know what? I'm tired of not playing...
Know the PHEEBLE chat server?
Well...
Link: PHEEBLE
Thing is, it's hosted at a certain IP address: http://66.135.33.167/
Now... It does redirect to a certain ezblog.co does it not?

Cabal's chat server is hosted in that same server. Also, Intro1 is Angelus invitation to chat, yet he does not provide the key to join the chat. Still, Pyramus joins anyway in Intro2. Which means the key to active chat was given somehow. If we assume they hacked into the ezblog account to hide the chat client, the key could be in there. I didn't try to crack the stuff... But I won't pretend I didn't notice.

Tara's blog was also discarded at first and proved to be linked to Don's storyline. Thoughts?

[NeverSlender]

You know what? I'm tired of not playing...
Know the PHEEBLE chat server?
Well...
Link: PHEEBLE
Thing is, it's hosted at a certain IP address: http://66.135.33.167/
Now... It does redirect to a certain ezblog.co does it not?

Cabal's chat server is hosted in that same server. Also, Intro1 is Angelus invitation to chat, yet he does not provide the key to join the chat. Still, Pyramus joins anyway in Intro2. Which means the key to active chat was given somehow. If we assume they hacked into the ezblog account to hide the chat client, the key could be in there. I didn't try to crack the stuff... But I won't pretend I didn't notice.

Tara's blog was also discarded at first and proved to be linked to Don's storyline. Thoughts?

Hmmmmmm... Gimme a minute to read through it.