Watch the Footage archive

Oh! "Odd man out"-- defeat and hunger both have 6 letters (the same, and even). Preparation has 11 (different, and odd).
Someone want to try that?

Qara-Xuan Zenith wrote:Oh! "Odd man out"-- defeat and hunger both have 6 letters (the same, and even). Preparation has 11 (different, and odd).
Someone want to try that?

Someone already did. No dice.

I tried AShadowUnderTheIce.ezblog.co and as a password for Pheeble, but nothing.

JackAlsworth wrote:

Qara-Xuan Zenith wrote:Oh! "Odd man out"-- defeat and hunger both have 6 letters (the same, and even). Preparation has 11 (different, and odd).
Someone want to try that?

Someone already did. No dice.

Yup. I'm not that great at riddles but I gave it a shot anyways xD;

What if it's "Odd Man?"

You can eat to stave off hunger, and you can choose to prepare, but defeat isn't entirely under your control. (someone want to try that?)

The Finch wrote:What if it's "Odd Man?"

Devious, but I don't think so. He wants an explanation, too.

The Finch wrote:What if it's "Odd Man?"

Tried. Waiting for answer.

While the guesses are fairly clever, they're also getting more pedantic. Remember, all of the cat's riddles thus far have had a point, even if they seemed random. Like the "shadow under the ice" one he said was foreshadowing.

Hope I havr the right riddle here, Twitter is tricky to navigate without an account...

One of these is the odd man out: preparation, defeat, hunger. Can you tell me which one and why?

Defeat, maybe?

Hunder and preparation are both building up to something, the chance of something being gained, or potential ahead, but Defeat signals the END of something and things being lost.

I just asked, apparently "man" is unimportant.

I'm completely lost. Should we extract an Anagram from there or something?

Pixelmage wrote:I'm completely lost. Should we extract an Anagram from there or something?

I doubt it. has anybody suggested defeat? Defeat is the end of soemthing, a conclusive point, but preparation and hunger are full of longing and possibilities.

Wait, at this point has EVERYTHING been suggested?

[quote="AVeryMadCat]It is not about the words themselves, but the context in which they can be properly used [/quote]

Well, that clears that up!

(New guess: "preparation" can't be used as a verb; defeat and hunger can.)

Yeah, that was my guess. After a mistaken "Hunger's the only verb" tweet, that is . Wouldn't 'cha know I'm an English major?

So, the words themselves are too concrete, and my answer was too abstract. What is he looking for?

What about defeat as you can prepare a meal, and you can hunger for one, but defeat is a completely different kettle of fish.

Has anybody tried that?

Asking right now, Scarab. Thanks!

Zup wrote:Asking right now, Scarab. Thanks!

Someone has already tried that a while ago.

Sicon112 wrote:

Zup wrote:Asking right now, Scarab. Thanks!

Someone has already tried that a while ago.

Well, crud, I'm stumped then

One of us must have gotten it right - there are only three options, so it's just figuring out the WHY, now...

My poor brain. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. I don't know.

Preparation is concrete-- people usually have some physical instance of preparation. Whereas hunger and defeat are more abstract; you can't prove either one to someone else. (anyone want to try it?)

Edit: He gave us another hint--

Cheshire Cat wrote:How can you USE this odd man out? It's about the context in which *you* can use them

So how about: We can use preparation and hunger to achieve something; defeat is an ends, not a means.

Maybe the answer is Hungry Man.

It's a type of food brand, and would be the only "Man" out of those 3.

The Finch wrote:Maybe the answer is Hungry Man.

It's a type of food brand, and would be the only "Man" out of those 3.

Word man confirmed to not be important.